Go back a page
Family News

In Japan, Brokered Marriages Struggle
Foreign brides greeted with hard work, exacting in-laws and little love


April 24, 1999

KNIGHT-RIDDER NEWS SERVICE

YAMAGATA, Japan -- She paints a detailed portrait of her loving, rustic family life, but none of it is true.
For nearly two hours, "Irene," a slim, brown-haired Filipina with a weak smile, a faraway gaze and a designer purse, described her brokered marriage to a Japanese farmer twice her age, a union that has produced two children.
"My in-laws accept me," the 30-year-old woman said as her 6-year-old daughter tinkered with a portable video game. "They are happy to have my support. None of the other Filipinos who've moved to my town to marry have suffered a divorce."
As soon as she has departed, psychiatrist Norihiko Kuwayama revealed the unhappy truth.
"This couple is a speechless pair," Kuwayama said of Irene and her Japanese farmer-husband, who have been married for 13 years. "They have no family life. Every night, Irene works in a bar selling drinks and waiting on customers, and I worry about who will take care of the children."
Kuwayama, 36, who helps run a hot line to help rural brides cope with their troubled marriages, said that at one point Irene went back to the Philippines and left one of her children behind.
"The husband didn't seem to care," he said. "We were surprised when she came back."
The couple has not had sex since Irene became pregnant with her youngest child, Kuwayama said.
Here in the snow-capped, rugged mountain regions of northern Japan, rural, rice-growing towns are shrinking as young men and women abandon the rigors of farm life for the anonymous freedom of Japan's giant cities.
Japanese custom affords no such freedom to the family's oldest son, however. According to rural tradition, the eldest male must stay to care for his aging parents and inherit the family land.
The situation has led to a shortage of eligible women in rural villages.
"More women are working now, and don't want to stay in the village," said marriage broker Setsuko Takano, whose tiny village of Shirataka has seen most of its young women leave.
"Last year, we had only 127 babies in this town," said Takano, who doubles as the local tailor. "At that rate, we'd have to close the schools soon. The very existence of the town itself is facing a crisis."
So Shirataka and dozens of other hamlets throughout Yamagata prefecture have encouraged families to spend more than $25,000 each to import brides from China, South Korea, Thailand and the Philippines. In 1997, the Japanese Justice Ministry issued 274,000 residency visas for foreign spouses of Japanese citizens, an increase of 30 percent in five years.
But according to psychiatrist Kuwayama, of the more than 1,000 marriages arranged for Japanese men and foreign women in his prefecture, fewer than 1 percent are happy.
The women who come from poor Asian nations are attracted by the relative prosperity of Japan, by far Asia's most prosperous economy even after years of a crippling recession. Many said they would feel guilty about walking out of their bad marriages because of the large amount of money their husbands' families paid to bring them to Japan.
The money they earn in Japan helps ease the poverty of relatives back home, and if their husbands divorced them, most of the women would be forced to leave Japan -- possibly without their children.
As Irene put it, "I was 17 years old and I thought it might be fun and exciting [to marry a Japanese]. After four months here, I got pregnant. I didn't marry for love. But if I got married to a Filipino man, it might have been worse. In the Philippines it's hard to find a job."
Even when a man and woman are compatible, Japanese xenophobia sometimes gets in the way.
Nipapon Umetsu, a bright-eyed Thai woman with two young children, said she gets along well with her Japanese husband, whom she met when he visited Thailand. But she doesn't feel welcomed by local residents and says she suffers discrimination at the plant where she works.
"When we make a mistake, they are very hard on us, but when a Japanese does something wrong, they are easily forgiven," she said. "The villagers look at us like we're different. They never talk to us. Sometimes I feel like they're looking down at me."
Communities in rural Japan, where families have often lived together for five or six generations, are not especially welcoming to outsiders, even to Japanese who grew up in other parts of the country, Kuwayama acknowledged.
"But these foreign wives don't speak the language and get married to a stranger with no information and no love. So it's a very stressful situation."
Exacerbating the domestic problems, residents admit, is the fact that many of the Japanese husbands are still subservient to their mothers.
"Honestly speaking, the men themselves are not attractive, that's the problem," said Takano, the marriage broker.

© Copyright 1999, The Salt Lake Tribune


If you are interested in additional information, or would like to set up a Families Worldwide Chapter in your community, please feel free to contact us via e-mail.

Families Worldwide
75 East Fort Union Blvd.
Salt Lake City, UT 84047
USA


Fax us: USA 801/562-6008,
or Call us: USA 801/562-6185

Send comments and mail to Webmaster

 Home    About FWW    Newsletter    Programs & Services    Calendar of Events
 Family News    Articles and Research     Family Links
Member Organizations & Affiliates
Families Worldwide