Go back a page
Family News

He cheated - now what?
Throwing him out and opting for divorce a mistake, therapists say

Thursday, March 25, 1999

By Steve Payne
Toronto Sun

A good-looking rich doctor in the nation's capital, he seemingly had it all: Beautiful wife and kids, gorgeous house, great car.

Then sex reared its head. He liked it, his wife didn't.

So, despite adoring his family, when other women beckoned he willingly dropped his pants.

Eventually, realizing the error of his ways, he took drastic measures to get his wife's attention.

Incredibly, he purposely timed a tryst at home so his wife would walk in and catch him making out.

"He was so tired of sneaking around with other women that he wanted to get caught," says Ottawa sex therapist Sue McGarvie. "He loved his lifestyle and family but because his wife had a low sex drive, this was his way of confronting it."

His wife threw him out.

'WORKED THROUGH IT'

Two weeks later they met for a clear-the-air dinner.

Get yourself some counselling, the scorned wife demanded, then we'll get therapy together.

"They worked through it and are back with each other," says McGarvie, who helped the couple.

Adultery is commonplace.

Put any 14,000 couples in Maple Leaf Gardens and chances are at least half will have been unfaithful.

Naturally, the usual reaction to adultery is to give the cheat his permanent marching orders.

Bad idea, according to the therapists.

"Adultery is a brush with death, a dysfunctional attempt to stabilize a relationship," says New York family therapist and author Dr. Bonnie Eaker Weil. "Look at it as a cry for help, a wake-up call. Don't throw him out and call a divorce lawyer."

The author of Adultery: The Forgiveable Sin, she says the victim may have contributed to the sexual wandering.

Wives may spend too much time with a new baby, she says, or work so hard that the partner gets short-changed.

Whatever the case, she recommends counselling.

"Most people who fell in love together want to stay together," she says.

Therapists say sensible, well-thought-out responses to philandering can often mend or even strengthen marriages.

For one thing, some counsellors argue there's a difference between a one-night stand and a secretive, long-term affair.

One dabble, perhaps, is more forgivable than a dozen.

"I would be more concerned about who my husband was having coffee with at work than with a one-night transgression," says McGarvie, "but I would not encourage it."

She says get the cheater "out of your face" for a while, but adds, "Don't be too quick to throw in the towel completely."

At some stage, she continues, decisions must be made on whether to get back together or split permanently.

She suggests therapy, saying, "An affair may be a cry for help, a catalyst to start talking honestly."

Apart from the couple sorting out their own feelings, experts say social status, finances and religion can play a part. Children, if there are any, are a significant factor.

Kids can feel responsible for a parental break-up, become a pawn or be encouraged to take sides, say therapists. They may also be guilt-ridden when they've done no wrong.

Therapists insist that both parents must reassure kids of their love for them and emphasize they're not to blame.

In her book, The Complete Idiot's Guide To A Healthy Relationship, clinical psychologist Dr. Judy Kuriansky says major reasons why people cheat are the monotony of daily routine; sexual boredom; unexpressed anger; increased opportunities for adultery and life crises.

But "despite the heartbreak that comes with infidelity, couples can still make their love work," she says.

'CHECKLIST'

Victims have to accept and face the anger, depression and distrust, she says, talk to their partner about their relationship and see if a new commitment to each other is possible.

In her "affair survival checklist," Kuriansky suggests time out; re-examining attitudes on commitment and monogamy; showing compassion to each other; counselling and lifestyle changes to allow for time together.

Marriage and family therapist Orville Green, an associate with the Institute of Family Living in Toronto, says each case of adultery has different circumstances to consider.

He says that if as a result of a previous affair it was a condition that a repeat would end the marriage, then kicking a cheating spouse out is reasonable.

"If it's a first-time affair then telling them to leave may not be the best way," he says.

He says allow a cooling-off period and then talk.

"I suggest counselling because when couples talk alone, emotions may get in the way of arriving at any sensible decision," he says.

"I do not know what the right reaction is to finding out about an affair," says sex and marriage therapist Dr. Robert Langford. "That's it, you're outa' here may be justified.

"There's a natural feeling of anger, a betrayal of trust, but what's said today is not necessarily the same as a week later," adds Langford, a University of Toronto professor.

Copyright © 1999, Canoe Limited Partnership.


If you are interested in additional information, or would like to set up a Families Worldwide Chapter in your community, please feel free to contact us via e-mail.

Families Worldwide
75 East Fort Union Blvd.
Salt Lake City, UT 84047
USA


Fax us: USA 801/562-6008,
or Call us: USA 801/562-6185

Send comments and mail to Webmaster

 Home    About FWW    Newsletter    Programs & Services    Calendar of Events
 Family News    Articles and Research     Family Links
Member Organizations & Affiliates

Families Worldwide